Effect of Mechanical Disturbances During and After Acid Etching on Shear Bond Strength
Objectives: To study the effect of mechanical disturbances during and after acid etching on shear bond strength and their debonding characteristics.Materials and methods: An in vitro study was performed taking 60 extracted human first premolars divided equally in three groups. Samples in Group A were bonded according to manufacturer instructions; in Group B, they were etched by rubbing a sponge that contained 37% orthophosphoric acid over the enamel for 15 s, and then bonded, and in Group C they were etched for 15 s, washed and air dried. After etching and drying, they were rubbed with a dry sponge for 5 s and then bonded. Shear bond strength testing was performed.Results: The differences in bond strengths and adhesive remnant index (ARI) scores between the groups were assessed by one-way ANOVA test and Post hoc Tukey test. Both the tests revealed statistically significant differences for bond strengths and ARI scores. Group A shows higher values for bond strength (13.825 MPa) as compared with Group B (12.996 MPa) and Group C (10.146 MPa). Group A shows higher values for ARI (3.89) as compared with Group B (3.55) and Group C (1.8).Conclusion: Mechanical disturbances during and after acid etching reduce the shear bond strength of composite resin. Etchant and primer should be applied on the tooth surface by dabbing the solutions.