Judicial Compromise in Rape Cases: A Critical Analysis of V. Mohan v. State (2015) and Its Implications

It has become a judicial trend in India emphasis is consistently placed on the concepts of dishonour and reputation rather than on the violation of the victim’s bodily autonomy by the perpetrator in cases of sexual offences. Compromise in which the accused marries the victim is often seen as a solution by the judges in rape cases to indemnify the ‘dishonour’ that has been caused to the victim. It is not unusual for courts in India to grant bail to an accused because of their marriage to the victim during the pendency of the case or to dismiss cases based on subsequent marriage. Although the High Court has inherent jurisdiction to safeguard justice under Section 482 of the CrPC, the landmark judgement in Gian Singh v. State of Punjab (2012) made it clear that grave offences like rape could not be quashed by the court even if it was compromised between the victim and the offender, that it cannot have any legal sanction. This judgement was given in 2012, and after three years, the order in V. Mohan v State granted bail to the accused on the condition of settling the case through mediation. This paper critically analyses V. Mohan v State (2015 SCC OnLine Mad 3578), a Madras High court order in a criminal appeal, wherein bail was granted to the accused. This paper scrutinizes the misapplication of precedents and the use of gender-biased reasoning in the judgement. It also examines how “marry-your-rapist” laws, which do not exist in books, are applied by the judiciary through their judicial orders and judgements. This research explores the legal framework relating to sentencing in rape cases, highlighting key Supreme Court decisions that caution against the compounding of serious offences like rape.

View article page

Download PDF