Rethinking Credibility and Justice in the State of Kerala v. Bishop Franco Mulakkal: Challenging the ‘Ideal Rape Victim’ Construct

‘Judiciary’ -the third pillar of democracy in India, the protector and preserver of the fundamental rights of the citizens. However, when the protector becomes the one who does not preserve the integrity and dignity of its citizens, what expectation can one have from society? Women in a country like India have faced many stereotypes as to how an ideal woman should behave. Time and again, the judges in the court have showcased the influence of such a stereotypical view while rendering judgments and deducing the parameters which define how an ideal victim of rape should behave. Such a misogynistic view leads to the normalization of rape culture, where we blame the victim and not holding the perpetrators responsible who are actually behind the commission of such an act. The remarks made in the judgment of the State of Kerala v. Bishop Franco Mulakkal by the sessions court are an example of judges holding the victim’s behavior as not ideal according to the situation’s demand. Hence, credibility was questioned on this ground. The article critically analyses the obiter dicta of the judgment made by the judges in this case.

View article page

Download PDF