Justice in Question: Analyzing the Two-Finger Tests in Light of Lillu @ Rajesh and Another v. State of Haryana

The two-finger test is a kind of test that is used to determine whether the survivor of the rape or sexually assaulted is habituated to sexual intercourse which by its nature sounds very degrading. The test is an 18th-century old test where it involves determining the laxity of the vagina and the extent of the broken hymen to determine the victim’s sexual records. On the face of it, such determination of a woman’s sexuality is an inhuman practice that not only breaches the woman’s bodily autonomy and integrity but at the same time is disrespectful to the character of a woman and hence should be banned immediately. This notion was considered after the horrific incident of the Delhi Gang Rape Case, 2013, popularly known as the Nirbhaya case, wherein the Justice Verma Committee recommended the discontinuation of the two-finger test case. However not long, in 2019, a gang rape case happened in the Singrauli district of Madhya Pradesh, the police authorities conducted the two-finger test and after the reports stated in the press media that the said girl victim was habituated to sexual activity. In this paper, we shall emphasise the need to have uniform strict guidelines where the governments should ensure that such tests should immediately be refrained for forensic examination because a mere two-finger test is not the sole manner of deciding a woman’s sexual history. Moreover, such kind of tests are a direct violation of Article 21 of the Indian Constitution which grants every person in the country to live a dignified life and the Right to Privacy laws - which women is completely stripped of because of the frequent practise of such test, and which needs to have a closure.

View article page

Download PDF