Analysis of the Shakti Mill Gang Rape Case: Understanding the Concept of Repeat Offender and Rarest of Rare Doctrine

Rape is considered one of the gravest of all offences, even more than that of murder. Various amendments are continuously being bought to the criminal laws with the hope of lowering the number of rape cases. Stricter punishments are being implemented; however, it is certainly not proven enough to check the increasing rate of rape cases each year. Shakti Mill Gangrape case is one of such infamous cases that shook the conscience of our nation. In this case, the Trial Court, with high hopes of spreading effective deterrence, convicted the accused and punished them with death. However, the Bombay High Court was of a different opinion, stating that life imprisonment can cause the same level of deterrence as Capital Punishment and considering all the softening factors commuted the death penalty. In this article, the researcher will critically analyze the facts, judgement and obiter dicta in the Shakti Mills Rape case and finally conclude as to whether it was a sound decision to have commuted punishment of such repeat offenders.

View article page

Download PDF