“Women of Easy Virtue”: Judicial Bias and the Undermining of Justice in Rape Cases
“I measure the progress of a community by the degree of progress which women have achieved”--B. R. AMBEDKAR. The goal of this paper is to conduct a comprehensive critique of the language employed by the criminal courts in sentencing and, in particular, how the language illustrates biases that certain societal standards ascribe to victims and offenders in society, particularly violence against women. This paper, by investigating the Judges’ comments, looks at the mention of women’s issues as well as their impact on the sentence, and in doing so, highlights a certain incongruence between the law and feminism. Given a discourse analysis, the work attempts to trace certain judicial discourse patterns which tend to encourage stereotypical notions of gender which often undercut violence against women. The paper proposes a shift from the current judicial approach that focuses more on the offender and aims at the victims’ needs instead and recommends that the judiciary should undergo training aimed at removing gender prejudice to promote public trust in the justice system and integrity within the judiciary. The paper also engages with ongoing debates concerning the proper conduct of the judiciary regarding women’s position to examine the Musauddin Ahmed case in detail.