Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 2019 and the reconfiguration of India’s Citizenship Regime

The Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 2019 (CAA 2019) privileges religious persecution as the basis upon which immigrants from certain religious communities have been provided with the right to apply for citizenship in India by registration or naturalization. The paper attempts to identify whether the discursive effect of privileging religious persecution as the determining principle orients India’s citizenship regime towards a preferential direction, where the basis of preference is an individual’s religious identity. It has been done by identifying and examining the discursive mechanisms deployed by political and juridical institutions to rationalize the classificatory category of religious persecution as essential to achieving the objective of the law. The paper delineates doctrinal studies of judgments by the Supreme Court of India and highlights the principles following which the said classificatory category has been upheld as the logical premise for the intelligible bracketing of specific religious communities by the Act. The discursive premise of the said principles is then ascertained by examining the Hindu Nationalist discourse and the literature on the Constituent Assembly Debates (CAD) of India. Thereby demonstrating which discourses concerning religious persecution have been recontextualized in the aforementioned acts, leading up to the CAA 2019. Following Mouffe, Anupama Roy argues that the outsider is constantly constituted in the delineations of citizenship as a reflection of the citizen by building a relationship of ‘forclusion’, which manifests itself through the dual processes of encompassment and closure. The paper deliberates upon the discursive mechanisms, expressed in the political, juridical and legal spheres, by which the incongruent relationship between the outsider and the citizen is transformed in light of the CAA 2019, consequentially leading to a transformation of the latter’s identity, whereby India’s citizenship regime is led towards a pref

View article page

Download PDF