A Discourse on the Case of Pranjal Shukla v. State of Uttar Pradesh (2024) Allahabad High Court
Judges are respected for their wisdom and legal eminence. They can hear convincing arguments from both sides without being wavered by their persuasion. They are adjudicators and interpreters of the law. Unlike laypeople, they do not give in to speculation but confine their judgment to facts, evidence and the letters of the law. Nevertheless, it would be inaccurate to depict them as completely impartial. They have their own biases. These biases may be reflected through their remarks and comments, which sometimes form part of their judgment. Judges, unlike lawyers, have a higher responsibility of being judicious in giving their opinion. This responsibility is even higher when they are dealing with cases of sexual offences against women. They must take precautions and not let their prejudices take over them. This is a serious issue as these remarks can have a damaging impact on the society. Thus, the judges must follow self-restraint when delivering judgments in such cases and keep in mind that they do not digress from the confines of the law.