Unpacking ‘Bengal Exceptionalism’ vis-à-vis Governance
The lecture looks at ‘exceptionalism’ in terms of Bengal’s historical and cultural identity as both self-identity and strife. The ‘Bengal tradition’ forms the basis of a dialectical relationship with governance (and law), where a disengagement from governance, and by extension its power politics, creates a counter-force. This relationship must be understood by acknowledging a dynamic of governance recognition fighting a historical impulse to resist. The lecture takes a non-linear approach to time and suggests that no understanding of independence and governance in India can treat Bengal as the exception that proves the rule, but rather as a valuable historical movement in its own right. While developing ‘exceptionalism’, the lecture discusses the various historical phases of governance in Bengal. It notes that particularly for the Bengali community, a history of marginalization that began under colonialism, political exclusion that has followed independence, and the imbalances of representation, especially at the national level. In this process, the lecture reveals the ways that a sense of deprivation has contributed to multiple perceptions of cultural autonomy. In this way, exceptionalism has been mutable in regards to political oppositionality, while it has remained constant for respect as a way of life. In conclusion, it is stated that Bengal’s tradition of exceptionalism, is also dynamic and plural rather than fixed.