Can Restorative Justice Empower Victims of Sexual Violence? A Critical Analysis from Global Perspectives
The discussion around the effectiveness and suitability of Restorative Justice (RJ) practices in cases of sexual violence is intricate and often controversial. Critics frequently raise concerns about the potential for revictimization, re-traumatization, and the power imbalances that may put victims and or survivors at a disadvantage during these processes. This article seeks to offer a critical review of existing literature and empirical studies on the use of RJ in sexual violence cases. It aims to advocate that when RJ is implemented with an emphasis on victim and or survivor leadership and accompanied by specialized training for practitioners, it can serve as a valuable alternative to traditional, mostly punitive measures of the Criminal Justice System. The analysis, primarily focusing on five jurisdictions, i.e., Australia, New Zealand, South Africa, Canada, and India, seeks to incorporate results from a small-scale survey of academics, policymakers, and practitioners. It aims to reveal a cautiously optimistic perspective on the applications of RJ in sexual violence crimes so as to empower victims from a victims’ justice lens, highlighting the need for more informed public discussions and research about RJ. Additionally, this article aims to address the problematic attitudes towards rape within the Criminal Justice System, stressing the importance of a paradigm shift that views sexual violence as a crime against individuals rather than a societal issue. It calls for a new perspective that recognizes the gendered dimensions and power dynamics implicit in these crimes.