Case Comment: State of Madhya Pradesh v. Surendra Singh – A Sentencing Perspective under the New Criminal Laws
The Supreme Court of India’s decision in State of Madhya Pradesh v. Surendra Singh (2015) is a significant pronouncement on the scope of judicial discretion in sentencing and its potential to undermine justice if misapplied. The absence of codified sentencing guidelines in India creates wide variations in punishments for similar offences, often eroding public faith in the fairness of the criminal justice system. In comparison to the United States and the United Kingdom, India’s criminal court system lacks a clear and strict sentencing policy. There is not only a need to consider the revengeful attitude of the victim, but also, with time, going beyond punishment and reforming the accused should be reflected in sentencing decisions. The replacement of India’s colonial-era criminal codes—the Indian Penal Code (IPC), Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC), and Indian Evidence Act (IEA) with the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), and Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam (BSA) represents a major legislative reform. While the structural changes are significant, the foundational principles of criminal liability, procedure, and evidence remain largely intact. This commentary revisits State of Madhya Pradesh v. Surendra Singh (2015), a case of rash and negligent driving causing death, through the lens of the new statutes. It examines how the offences, procedural safeguards, and evidentiary standards translate under the new laws, and whether the reforms meaningfully address the problem of sentencing disparity. The Supreme Court’s insistence on proportionate punishment in this case is as relevant under the BNS-BNSS-BSA regime as it was under the earlier IPC-CrPC-IEA framework. The analysis concludes that without structured sentencing guidelines, judicial discretion will continue to pose challenges to consistency and fairness.