The Question of Rules of Expert Opinion and IPD: A Discussion in the Context of the New Himachal Pradesh Intellectual Property Division and Comparative Developments Across Emerging Indian IPDs
India’s IP Law regime has undergone a transformative change since the abolition of the IPAB in 2021. The State High Courts are in the process of developing IPDs as part of the State High Courts. The Delhi HC was the first High Court to develop such a division. Soon, the Madras HC and the Calcutta HC followed suit. Himachal Pradesh HC is the latest High Court to develop such a division. These IP divisions have their own rules. These IPD rules seem more or less congruent from afar. Expert opinion is an integral part of IP jurisprudence, being relevant in the IP office to the IP Courts. However, the IPD rules, when viewed in the context of the rules applicable to the experts or expert engagement, fissures appear. The objective of this article is to identify these fissures or incongruencies in the rules. With the increase in commercial and overall economic growth, India is at the cusp of being a leading innovator in the World. The Courts of such a leading innovator may incorporate the best practices of the world, but ought to maintain uniformity of rules in the national courts. This comment will include a study of the IPD and its rules in the infancy of its development, so that India’s IP future may lead to a future of consistency and credibility.