When Justice Reinforces Patriarchy: Reflections on Sentencing in Crimes against Women through the Aparna Bhat v. State of Madhya Pradesh Judgement
There have been numerous cases in recent times where a deeply patriarchal and sexist attitude has been portrayed in judicial orders and judgements. Judges have commented on women’s character, referred rape cases to mediation, and set ridiculous bail conditions in cases of gender-based violence. Hearing the appeal in one such case where the bail condition was for the complainant to tie a Rakhi on the accused, the Supreme Court collectively addressed this critical issue of gender insensitivity that permeates the Indian judiciary in the landmark case of Aparna Bhat v. State of Madhya Pradesh in 2021. The Court not only dealt with the impugned bail order but also set guidelines for handling cases involving crimes against women. This article aims to critically examine the controversial bail order and the Supreme Court judgement that is bound to be an important precedent for cases of gender-based violence in the times to come.