Personality Rights and Digital Misappropriation in the Age of AI: A Case Study of Jackie Shroff vs. The Peppy Store
The current case comment examines the famous temporary order issued by the Delhi High Court in the case of Jackie Shroff v. The Peppy Store & Ors. (2024), which deals with the misuse of celebrities’ personalities through AI-generated impersonations and the unauthorised commercial use of these personalities in digital format. The Court recognised personality rights, including rights to name, image, voice, and mannerisms, as falling within the right to privacy under Article 21 of the Indian Constitution, despite the lack of detailed statutory provisions in this area. The analysis is structured around three main aspects: (i) legal arguments presented by the parties, (ii) doctrinal foundations upon which the Court relied, and (iii) the Court’s reasoning, especially in relation to Indian precedents, statutory overlaps including the Information Technology Rules 2021 and the Data Protection and Privacy in Digital Personal Data Act 2023 and comparisons with U.S. legal and policy frameworks related to publicity rights and the EU General Data Protection Regulation. The comment critiques the Court’s reasoning adversely, highlighting issues related to intermediary liability and the challenges posed by deepfakes and AI mimicking technology. It concludes with a call for legislation that is more comprehensive in safeguarding digital identity in the era of generative content and synthetic media.