The Unwritten Sunset Clause of Personal Liberty in UAPA: Analysing Romila Thapar vs. Union of India
India’s principal anti-terrorism statute, the “Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act”, has faced mounting criticism for its impact on procedural safeguards and personal freedoms. Enacted in 1967 and repeatedly amended to broaden state authority, the law notably lacks a sunset clause—a key feature of its predecessors like TADA—resulting in unchecked state discretion. This paper contends that UAPA’s stringent provisions, including extended detention before trial of up to 180 days, a reversed burden of proof, and restrictive bail norms, function as an implicit “sunset clause” by systematically undermining personal liberty. The study critically examines “Romila Thapar v. Union of India (2018),” a pivotal case concerning the arrest of activists regarding the Bhima Koregaon incident. It highlights how the statute’s ambiguous terminology, such as “terrorist act,” coupled with procedural asymmetries, facilitates its misuse against dissenting voices. The Supreme Court’s 2:1 verdict, which denied an independent probe, illustrates judicial deference to executive power, whereas Justice Chandrachud’s dissent underscores concerns over trial by media, dilution of the presumption of innocence, and broader threats to democratic values. Statistical analysis between 2015 and 2020 reveals a stark pattern of misuse, with 98.78% of individuals arrested under UAPA classified as undertrials, yet only 2.8% securing convictions. Despite these concerns, recent judicial decisions (KA Najeeb, Sheikh Javed Iqbal) signal a shift towards prioritising constitutional principles over statutory rigidity. The paper ultimately asserts that while national security remains paramount, UAPA’s framework disproportionately compromises civil liberties. It calls for urgent legislative and judicial recalibration to ensure alignment with India’s constitutional vision, encapsulated in Chimanlal Shah’s assertion: “The right to life and personal liberty is the most fundamental of the fundamental rights.”