The Corroboration Conundrum: A Review of the Impact of Forensic and Medical Evidence in Rape Trials in India

This paper is an extensive literature review on the impact of forensic and medical evidence on rape trials in India. The major argument is that systemic failures in evidence collection, preservation, and presentation create a ‘corroboration conundrum’ that undermines justice for victims. Despite precedents permitting conviction based on the sole testimony of a victim if trustworthy and unblemished, Indian courts often fail to rely on such victim testimony. Rather, the courts often rely on delayed or compromised medico-legal evidence. Critical issues, such as the ‘24-hour rule’ for medical examination calculated from reporting, not the incident, often render such evidence inconclusive. The literature review synthesises existing scholarship to demonstrate how this evidentiary vacuum is routinely exploited to discredit victims, leading to high acquittal rates and extreme secondary victimisation. The paper concludes that such evidentiary reliance often transfers the burden of proof onto the victim’s body, which necessitates an urgent paradigm shift towards a victim-centric and victim testimony-focused jurisprudence.

View article page

Download PDF