Wheels of Nostalgia, Burden of Labour- A Constitutional and Policy Analysis of Kolkata�s Hand-Pulled Rickshaw Dilemma in Light of the Recent Matheran Judgment of the Supreme Court

On August 6, 2025, the Supreme Court of India, while hearing an interlocutory application in the popular �Godavarman� case, strongly reprimanded the inhumane custom of hand-pulled rickshaws as being inconsistent with the constitutional ethos of social justice and the contemporary ideals of equality. This judicial observation, while rooted in ecological protection, raises complex social questions concerning livelihood, labour dignity and ethical boundaries. In this context, the paper analyses the rationale behind the Supreme Court�s ban on these hand-pulled rickshaws and, by drawing a connection to Kolkata�s long-enduring practice of human-pulled rickshaws, it calls for an in-depth analysis of its continued persistence even in today�s globalised society. The paper then traces the historical origins of these rickshaws on the streets of Kolkata and examines the political dilemma and historical failure of the State in balancing the right to livelihood with the right to a dignified life, which has repeatedly thwarted legislative attempts to phase out this practice. The paper further analyses the appropriateness of the practice in light of constitutional principles emanating from various landmark judicial pronouncements and argues that balancing the right to a dignified life with the right to livelihood can translate these principles into a meaningful policy. Advocating the adoption of a Matheran-like framework in Kolkata, the paper finally concludes by highlighting the State�s responsibility in furthering the cause of social and economic justice and asserting that the protection of human dignity must prevail over exploitative traditions, even when those have acquired the status of �heritage�.

View article page

Download PDF