Performance of Selected KMA and Non-KMA Municipalities of West Bengal: Looking through the Combined Financial Management Performance Index
Municipal Financial Management Analysis-based research studies, especially on the fiscal health of municipalities in West Bengal, have been very scarce in recent times, and the available studies are largely confined to municipalities within the Kolkata Metropolitan Area (KMA). These analyses primarily focus on the solvency dimension, often overlooking other vital financial management dimensions. Against this backdrop, this paper concentrates on the analysis of the financial management of municipal bodies in West Bengal across all categories and groups by developing a Combined Financial Management Performance Index (CFMPI) based on eight indicator ratios under two vital yet less-explored dimensions, namely, Budget Implementation Management and Financial Autonomy, covering a ten-year period from 2012-13 to 2021-22. Furthermore, the study ranks selected municipalities based on index scores at the individual level as well as at the group and category levels. The study enables inter-municipal comparisons while also providing deeper insights into the structural inefficiencies and fiscal dependencies that influence municipal financial performance. The study found that, except for Haldia, most municipalities in West Bengal performed poorly in both Budget Implementation Management and Financial Autonomy. However, non-KMA municipalities performed slightly better than municipalities belonging to the KMA category, although their performance also remained far below acceptable benchmarks.