The Gap Between the Complexity of Accident Causation and Compliance-Based Investigation Practices in Indian Mines
Accident investigations in high-risk industries are intended to support organisational learning by identifying the systemic conditions that contribute to adverse events. Meaningful accident investigation requires moving beyond isolated procedural failures to examine how systemic structures and constraints shape unsafe outcomes. This study examines whether regulatory accident investigations reflect such a multi-level understanding or whether they create an illusion of causality by emphasising a narrow set of apparent sources, particularly violations of Standard Operating Procedures (SOP). Using official fatal accident narratives published by the Directorate General of Mines Safety (DGMS), India, a Bidirectional Encoder Representations from Transformers (BERT)- based topic modelling approach was applied to two textual components: (i) the original fatal accident narratives and (ii) the corresponding recommendations or counterfactual statements issued by the regulator. Topic modelling of the accident narratives revealed 13 distinct themes, including transportation-related accidents, roof collapses, explosions, equipment failures, and drowning. In contrast, the analysis of DGMS recommendations identified only three dominant topics, two of which were heavily centred on regulatory compliance with the Coal Mine Regulations and the Central Electricity Authority Regulations, together accounting for 91.25% of all cases. These findings demonstrate a clear mismatch between the multi-level complexity of accident causation and the compliance-focused framing adopted in regulatory investigations. The reliance on SOP violations as primary causal explanations may risk obscuring deeper systemic vulnerabilities. An explicit system-based approach is therefore essential to avoid the illusion of causality created by oversimplified explanations and support more effective learning and prevention in high-risk socio-technical systems.