An Empirical Investigation of Performance Efficacy of Debt ETFs in India
This study offers the initial empirical evidence on the performance behaviour of 14 Debt ETFs (comprising six G-Sec Index ETFs and eight Corporate Bond ETFs) of India relative to their benchmarks during 2015-2023. This study has employed a single factor-based Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM), three conventional (Sharpe, Treynor and Sortino Ratio) and two modified risk-adjusted return measures (Modified Sharpe and M-square Ratio), and three tracking error measures to assess the behaviour of Debt ETFs in India. The overall results of CAPM, different risk-adjusted and tracking error measures show that the sample Debt ETFs more or less move around the performance of their specific benchmark, indicating the presence of a full replication strategy. The findings of this study suggest that the Indian Debt ETF market is efficient itself and leaves minimal or negligible opportunities for managers to time the market. Considering the low risk, better transparency, liquidity and benchmark mirroring ability, Debt ETFs can be a viable alternative for risk-averse investors looking for bondlike investments in the wake of changing market realities. Major Findings: Evidence related to a full replication strategy in action is found. Very minimal divergence and tracking error from their respective benchmark is recorded. The findings indicate that the Indian Fixed Income ETF (FIETF) functions so efficiently that managers can scarcely time strategies.